There's nothing salacious about this post headline. Nothing at all.
Anyway, I washed out of the GDS3 competition in the multiple choice test, as expected. For fun, over at Goblin Artisans, I attempted the card design phase of the competition, which required you to make 10 cards for each color pairing, demanding various rarities and card types.
I ended up with blue and red at common, which screamed "instant" to me. It screamed that because there are soooo many blue/red instants and sorceries already. I wondered about doing something different with scry and came up with this.
While technically, scry could be in red, I decided that the mechanic of something happening if you put a card on the bottom of your deck felt very blue. I wonder how much design space there is there. I'd love to playtest this to see how much a player thinks about whether to put a card on the bottom so that he or she could deal damage.
And I was thinking about how the concept could fit in the Overgrowth set. I've been struggling with coming up with a solid blue legend (partly because I've been struggling with blue and white's identities in this set as a whole).
I genuinely cannot tell from looking at this whether she's overpowered or underpowered or just fine.
Edit: Days later I realize I put "deck" in the text of both spells instead of "library" like an idiot. Oy.
Saturday, February 24, 2018
Sunday, February 4, 2018
U/R Ability Word: Runic
I suspect I'm not the first wannabe designer to develop this ability word enter-the-battlefield concept.
Runic: When this spell is cast, if you've cast a sorcery or instant this turn already, there's some sort of a bonus.
Right now I have it concepted as blue/red for the obvious reason of them being the two colors who care most about sorceries and instants. And while it could appear in any type of spell, right now I have thematically typed as appearing on creatures only (and maybe artifacts). The idea is that, much like prowess, these creatures have a specific connection to magical energy and therefore benefit when spells are being flung around.
Very simple here. Very easy to understand. It is a very familiar template for enter-the-battlefield triggers. You could probably take every raid-triggered mechanic on blue/red creatures from Ixalan and retemplate them with this.
But I did hit an interesting snag with the templating on this blue creature:
The wording on this one is really awkward. I deliberately wanted this person to recover only the sorcery or instant cast this turn (essentially retaining the spell that triggered runic in the first place). But technically you don't need the "if you cast a sorcery or instant this turn" text, because it is written so that you can only recover something you've cast this turn. But if I leave that text out, it's a break from the templating.
Maybe this isn't even a "runic" creature at all? It's just a creature that lets you recover a spell you cast that turn. The ability word doesn't actually do anything here.
I don't think this mechanic would work well in the Overgrowth set. I feel like it competes with conceptual space with the mutate mechanic, which causes creatures to grow due to exposure to magic.
Tuesday, January 23, 2018
Magrazam and the Pyre Hermits
When Guthreham's wild growth started getting out of hand, many wizards that had been serving the Arbor (and many of which had fought in the wars) started using their magics to try to get things in hand.
Some mages with more controlling magics were embraced by Janell and the Arbor as a way of trying to keep things in check without suppressing the growth that Janell and her followers embraced. But pyromancers and other wizards with harsher, destructive magics found themselves on the outs. It was a clash of wills that threatened to turn violent. But Magrazam, an elder mage who once fought by Janell's side, could sense that Janell was much more powerful than others understood. He doesn't know what a planeswalker is, but he knows that there's a lot more to Janell than meets the eye.
So instead he and his fellow wizards threw up their hands and left, heading up to the Nightscrape Mountains and essentially became hermits and live on their own terms.
Then the plagues came and started infecting people, killing them and often zombifying them. Many of the infected were pushed off to the coast or into the ruins of the overgrown cities Guthreham has abandoned. But others wanted to be free of this brutal, unending life cycle entirely. Some diseased folks or families with dying members have taken a difficult trek up to the Nightscrape Mountains. They seek release in the flames. They want the pyre hermits to burn them into dust, freeing them from all the pestilence.
At first, the pyre mages would only burn corpses and fully zombified people. But increasingly they've agreed to essentially euthanize those who have reached the end stage of disease. Magrazam is increasingly concerned that they cannot remain on the sidelines of all this. He's also aware, thanks to the natural cavern networks delving deep into the mountains, that there are independently operating artifacts and artificial creatures in the bowels of the plane. He doesn't know how they got there or what they're for. He has no idea about Guthreham's secret, but he does suspect Janell is hiding something significant.
This is an example of the common land cycle. Each will have a second cheapish on-color ability that essentially "exerts" the land.
Edit: No, this needs to damage an opponent, not a creature. Too powerful at common. Silly me.
Some mages with more controlling magics were embraced by Janell and the Arbor as a way of trying to keep things in check without suppressing the growth that Janell and her followers embraced. But pyromancers and other wizards with harsher, destructive magics found themselves on the outs. It was a clash of wills that threatened to turn violent. But Magrazam, an elder mage who once fought by Janell's side, could sense that Janell was much more powerful than others understood. He doesn't know what a planeswalker is, but he knows that there's a lot more to Janell than meets the eye.
So instead he and his fellow wizards threw up their hands and left, heading up to the Nightscrape Mountains and essentially became hermits and live on their own terms.
At first, the pyre mages would only burn corpses and fully zombified people. But increasingly they've agreed to essentially euthanize those who have reached the end stage of disease. Magrazam is increasingly concerned that they cannot remain on the sidelines of all this. He's also aware, thanks to the natural cavern networks delving deep into the mountains, that there are independently operating artifacts and artificial creatures in the bowels of the plane. He doesn't know how they got there or what they're for. He has no idea about Guthreham's secret, but he does suspect Janell is hiding something significant.
This is an example of the common land cycle. Each will have a second cheapish on-color ability that essentially "exerts" the land.
Edit: No, this needs to damage an opponent, not a creature. Too powerful at common. Silly me.
Monday, January 22, 2018
Spurning Spurn ... and Bringing in Detain?
I think I've hit a "Kill Your Darlings" space. As much as I want to make "spurn" work as a mechanic, it just really isn't fitting into this set. Flavorwise, having it trigger from spells and activated abilities seems very much not in the spirit of a world that's worried about being overwhelmed by beasts and plagues. Mechanically, it doesn't create a win condition or really set one up because the effects are so varied and so reactive. White in particular is struggling for a play archetype given that it doesn't have access to either mutate or reave.
So "spurn" is out. There may still be spaces in the set where I can have white and blue punish opponents for lobbing spells at them. That fits well into what they're about in this set. I'm thinking of bringing detain in to replace spurn, the Azorius mechanic from Return to Ravnica. In the big Magic Design Search 3 essay test, we were asked to pick a mechanic to make evergreen. I chose detain, because it mechanically clarifies and clearly represents a host of existing stun mechanics that blue and white already use to keep opponents from using their creatures. So could I make a detain a mechanic blue and white use to hold opponents' creatures back to prepare their own armies?
I have decided I do want to make the burgeoning enchantments work. They actually better represent the growth concepts of this world than spurn did. I'm still not entirely sure about balance, power, rarity, and what to do when the options run out. I don't want them to just pop like a limp balloon. So I'm thinking at the very least, they cantrip once they're done.
Also an interesting bit of tension once you bring detain into this set. When you target a mutating creature with detain, it's going to get a+1/+1 counter. So you've successfully held the beast at bay, but it's feeding off your magic.
I decided to go with a "may" version on this one, and I'm wondering if it's going to cause memory issues. A player can decide not to use the first effect when his next upkeep comes around. So it will remain at that first effect for his or her next upkeep. Is that something a player would obviously realize?
Edit: I just realized that if it's a "may" effect, they can just leave it in play and never select the last step, which seems weird. I think the "may" has to be on the steps themselves. In which case I'm wondering if a player thinks they've chosen a step even if they decide not to detain any creatures. Complications!
Edit II: Since the steps require targeting an opponent's creatures, I think the "may" is not necessary. You don't have to worry about it backfiring on you (which would not be in the flavor for this one). It would just fizzle.
But fizzling creates a new gameplay concern. If an effect fizzles, does that still count as "chosen"? If there's no valid target for the first effect, what happens? Here's where things get messy. Normally you cannot cast a spell or use an ability when there's not a valid target.
So under the rules, can you even "choose" the first effect if your opponent has no creatures? So perhaps the first two items on the list require a "may."
So "spurn" is out. There may still be spaces in the set where I can have white and blue punish opponents for lobbing spells at them. That fits well into what they're about in this set. I'm thinking of bringing detain in to replace spurn, the Azorius mechanic from Return to Ravnica. In the big Magic Design Search 3 essay test, we were asked to pick a mechanic to make evergreen. I chose detain, because it mechanically clarifies and clearly represents a host of existing stun mechanics that blue and white already use to keep opponents from using their creatures. So could I make a detain a mechanic blue and white use to hold opponents' creatures back to prepare their own armies?
I have decided I do want to make the burgeoning enchantments work. They actually better represent the growth concepts of this world than spurn did. I'm still not entirely sure about balance, power, rarity, and what to do when the options run out. I don't want them to just pop like a limp balloon. So I'm thinking at the very least, they cantrip once they're done.
Also an interesting bit of tension once you bring detain into this set. When you target a mutating creature with detain, it's going to get a
I decided to go with a "may" version on this one, and I'm wondering if it's going to cause memory issues. A player can decide not to use the first effect when his next upkeep comes around. So it will remain at that first effect for his or her next upkeep. Is that something a player would obviously realize?
Edit: I just realized that if it's a "may" effect, they can just leave it in play and never select the last step, which seems weird. I think the "may" has to be on the steps themselves. In which case I'm wondering if a player thinks they've chosen a step even if they decide not to detain any creatures. Complications!
Edit II: Since the steps require targeting an opponent's creatures, I think the "may" is not necessary. You don't have to worry about it backfiring on you (which would not be in the flavor for this one). It would just fizzle.
But fizzling creates a new gameplay concern. If an effect fizzles, does that still count as "chosen"? If there's no valid target for the first effect, what happens? Here's where things get messy. Normally you cannot cast a spell or use an ability when there's not a valid target.
So under the rules, can you even "choose" the first effect if your opponent has no creatures? So perhaps the first two items on the list require a "may."
Sunday, January 21, 2018
Some Mutate Creatures
So for the set, the black and blue mutate creatures will be flavored as being afflicted with diseases, while the green and red mutate creatures will be the ones flavored as growing and reproducing out of control.
I've thought about some parasitic creatures and enchantments in black/blue that would allow for counters from creatures to be spent to cause effects, to sort of mechanically represent people studying and trying to use mutations for other ends. But I'm not entirely sure of the design space here, because I need to also make sure there's a decent number of friendly mutate triggers. You can't spend counters if it's too much trouble getting them in the first place. I'm still thinking about those drum enchantments. Now that I've changed spurn, they could still potentially work in the set. Not only can the by used for mutate triggers, your opponents use of the drum enchantments could trigger your own spurn abilities.
Tuesday, January 9, 2018
Spurn Version 3.0
That title is a lie. There have been like six iterations of this mechanic before getting to this point. But I think we may be there. Would you play this creature?
I think this is the cleanest, most intuitive representation of the concept of spurn. If an opponent gets aggressive toward you during your turn, you can punish them. Like "reave," this incarnation of spurn can be keyed to trigger just once when casting a spell or when a creature comes into play, or repeatedly, as is the case with this gull.
The design challenge is keeping it focused on a punish response that fits for blue/white/green colors. And I think this mechanic is too complex for common. But that's okay. This is a reactive mechanic, not a synergy-focused one. You don't build your deck around using spurn. Each card stands or fails on its own.
I think this is the cleanest, most intuitive representation of the concept of spurn. If an opponent gets aggressive toward you during your turn, you can punish them. Like "reave," this incarnation of spurn can be keyed to trigger just once when casting a spell or when a creature comes into play, or repeatedly, as is the case with this gull.
The design challenge is keeping it focused on a punish response that fits for blue/white/green colors. And I think this mechanic is too complex for common. But that's okay. This is a reactive mechanic, not a synergy-focused one. You don't build your deck around using spurn. Each card stands or fails on its own.
Mirroring Life vs. Death
Thinking about ways to mechanically represent the growing conflict between the "pure" creatures and people represented in green and white versus the plague-afflicted black and blue folks with mechanics that aren't necessarily mutate or reanimation.
Here's a common mirrored pair in green and black.
The rules text is maybe a little more complicated than it needs to be by referring to the battlefield rather than just creatures you control. But I wanted to make sure it was very clear what triggered the bonuses.
There is a question as to whether the mechanics are too complex for common. I don't think they are. It's very easy to check and not confusing.
Here's a common mirrored pair in green and black.
The rules text is maybe a little more complicated than it needs to be by referring to the battlefield rather than just creatures you control. But I wanted to make sure it was very clear what triggered the bonuses.
There is a question as to whether the mechanics are too complex for common. I don't think they are. It's very easy to check and not confusing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)













